|
The answer depends on what documents you consult and when they were published – ah! scholarship forges ahead (?) and I guess some scholars like nothing better than to outdo their predecessors. Headaches for lowly journalists…
Leaving aside religious, military, governmental and other public buildings, and if we’re talking about the oldest element(s) of a civil dwelling house extant in the capital, then the vestiges of what was probably a Gallo-Roman patrician’s home (between first and third centuries A.D.) you can visit in the Archaeological Crypt Museum beneath the esplanade in front of Notre Dame Cathedral are likely at or very near first place. |
Moving up from underground, there seems to be something of a consensus that the eldest is what’s left of the ground floor (since several times revamped) of 4 rue de la Colombe (Dove Street) on Ile de la Cité, originally built in the early 1200s by a mason/sculptor working on the construction of Notre Dame Cathedral.
A tavern opened there about 1240 - already a reconstruction of the original building, which had caved in during a major flood ca. 1220. |
|
According to legend, a pair of doves nested on the window sill of the mason/sculptor’s house. The flood-induced collapse trapped the female bird in the wreckage, but the male got away.
He brought her kernels of grain in his beak and water sucked from the nearby river in a straw until she could be freed. Whence not only the street’s name but also dove medallions on the walls of what is still a restaurant and wine store.
The Medieval masonry is obvious, on the left facing the main entrance.
“Without a doubt”: Oh really?
|
OK, but if we’re looking for the oldest entire house things get complicated. Jacques Hillairet’s monumental 1963 Dictionnaire Historique des Rues de Paris affirms that the half-timbered structure at 3 rue Volta, near La République, is “the oldest house in Paris … dating probably from the end of the 13th or beginning of the 14th century.”
The house certainly has a Medieval look about it, although curiously it lacks a cellar, a feature almost universal in Parisian dwellings around 1300. |
Despite this anomaly, Larousse’s collective 1964 Dictionnaire de Paris didn’t hesitate to state that 3 rue Volta “is said to be, without a doubt quite rightly, the oldest in Paris.”
As late as 1979, another collective book, the Guide de Paris Mystérieux, unabashedly repeated this affirmation, as did several successive editions of the Guide Vert Michelin to Paris.
As early as 1972, however, Dictionnaire Historique author Hillairet, and Pascal Payen-Appenzeller - his partner in preparing a supplementary update volume – , were indeed beginning to have doubts: “According to the latest studies concerning this house, it does not seem certain that it is ‘the oldest house in Paris’.”
The Supplément wonders if 3 rue Volta might not in fact be 16th century. By 1994, the Ile de France Regional Council’s official Guide du Patrimoine: Paris put it unequivocally: “long dated from the 13th or 14th century /this house/ is from the first half of the 17 th century.” Bye, 3 rue Volta!
Anyone for… alchemy?
Other candidates? Plaques on N°s 11 and 13 rue François Miron, near Saint Paul, claim they date from the 14 th century.
They were rather vigorously “refurbished” in the 1960s when Culture Minister André Malraux strove to bring the Marais out of the grimy industrial reconversion of noble townhouses during the 1800s that had disfigured much of the quarter and back to its old origins.
The 1994 Guide du Patrimoine wryly debunks the plaques: “Suggested datings range from the 14th to the 17th centuries. One could just as well date them from 1967, when they were ‘restored’.” |
|
Hmm… Where do we go from here? Well, let’s try a little… 15th century alchemy.
|
Towards the end of the 14th century, one Nicolas Flamel – a kind of notary public at the University – suddenly acquired considerable wealth.
Pious, he was a benefactor to no less than 14 hospitals, seven churches and three chapels. He used a good part of the fortune to build, in 1407 at 51 rue de Montmorency (not far from the Centre Pompidou), a boarding house for indigents who, in return for living there, were required to say daily an “Our Father” and a “Hail Mary” for the souls of the dead. |
Badly restored at the end of the 19th century, and now being – hopefully more carefully – refreshed, this is either “one of the oldest houses in Paris” (the 1994 Guide du Patrimoine) or, more simply and less prudently (Albert Ferro’s 1996 Histoire et Dictionnaire de Paris), “recognized as the oldest house in Paris.”
Whence the unexpected – or at least unexplained - fortune? Flamel and wife Pernelle apparently made real estate killings, and he may also have gotten his hands (less publicly) on the expropriated wealth of Jews expelled from France.
He has long been thought to have dabbled in alchemy, and claimed in his diary to have succeeded in turning mercury into silver and lead into gold. Or, more simply, was the house built with Pernelle’s magnificent dowry?
Game over?
|
Probably. But there was a close second: the Tour de Jean Sans Peur at 20 rue Etienne Marcel, near Saint Eustache Church.
Pro-English Duke of Burgundy, Jean Sans Peur ordered the assassination on 23 November 1407 of Louis d’Orléans, brother of King Charles VI – a murder that sparked civil war between the Burgundians and Armagnacs.
|
|
Scared silly, “Fearless John” had this fortified townhouse built – with his bedroom at the top of the keep-like tower the public can now visit - between 1409 and 1411. Lured from his lair eight years later, he in turn was assassinated. ---
* Paris-based Arthur Gillette guides theme- and period-specific strolls to help visitors discover “Paris Through The Ages.” If interested in taking one, or more, contact him on
Armedv@aol.com. |